When you see a movie on the World Trade Center followed a week later by one called “Snakes on a Plane,” you know the summer movie season is, sadly, over. How did it do this time around? For my part, I usually look back on what I saw, and, frankly, I feel like the crop didn’t live up to the hype. I will say this, though…I liked this year’s offerings better than last years, which, apart from Batman Begins and War of the Worlds, wasn’t wonderful. Here’s what I’ll do: In the following list, I’ll include my anticipation rank (how much I was looking forward to the movie) and my payoff rank (how much I enjoyed it), both on a scale of 1 to 5, five being highest.
The Da Vinci Code–AR:2, PR:2–I didn’t read the book, and since I had heard what the big secret was (maybe there was a *gasp* Mrs. Jesus!) before I saw it, without reading the book, I left feeling like I’d seen a movie that was okay, but too long and not adventurous enough. Which, for summer movies, is the chain and the anchor that pulls a summer movie into the cold, dark depths of forgettableness. Like that metaphor? Let’s segue to…
Poseidon–AR:3, PR:2–Pretty forgettable, Wolfgang Peterson’s direction notwithstanding. Eye candy is nice, but it only accentuates the problem many eye-candy movies have, and eye-candy disaster movies in particular: If you don’t know the characters, you don’t care if they die, even if it’s in spectacular ways.
X-Men The Last Stand–AR:3, PR:4–As a fan of comic books, movies, and comic book movies, I’ve closely watched the ongoing outcry of my geek bretheren following the announcement that Bryan Singer was exiting the franchise and handing the reins over to Brett Ratner, whose claim to fame is the fun-but-barely-registering Rush Hour movies. Verdict? I wasn’t expecting too much, so I was happy with what I got. And I grew up with these characters–I’ll talk some other time about the kick of watching a movie and knowing more about what’s going on than most others in the theater…
Superman Returns–AR:5, PR:3.5–Okay, I’ll say this–Superman the Movie is probably in my top three of all time. I’ve been waiting for this movie for, literally, a decade or more. When I found out Bryan Singer was directing, I was happy. When I found out it was taking place as a sequel following the also quite good Superman II, I was happy. I saw the movie, I left, and I was…pretty happy. I’ve talked to some other fans (we like to talk to each other; the one- eyebrow- raised- stare we get from everyone else is sometimes too much to take) and they feel the same. It wasgood. Sometimes very good. I just wanted great. I should have known…some things are just too good to happen twice.
Over the Hedge–AR:1, PR:4–I knew next to nothing about this when I saw it, except it was done by the guys who did Madagascar, a movie that I thought was fairly funny. I liked this one better. There were a couple times I laughed like crazy, and startled myself (I can be a little schizo at the movies). A nice surprise.
Moster House–AR:3, PR:3–I knew Robert Zemeckis was attached to this film in some way, and he’s awesome. The payoff? Fun. Not much beyond that. I saw it at a drive in while getting eaten alive by mosquitoes (don’t ask). Maybe the blood loss kept me from understanding any subtle nuances.
Miami Vice–AR:4, PR:2– I love Michael Mann–one of the great modern noir directors of our time. And he did get some of the coolness that he does better than anyone onto the screen. It’s just, I wished I had a better idea of what was going on. Plus, it’s a buddy cop film. Emphasis on buddy. Crockett and Tubbs barely seemed to have anything to say to each other, and that, my friend, is just wrong.
Nacho Libre AR:4, PR:3–The previews of this movie killed me and my wife. We’d quote lines from it to each other like it was an inside joke. Then we saw it, and, aside from some other funny bits, realized the preview was funnier (and cheaper). Oh well.
Cars–AR:3, PR:3–This one had all Pixar’s pizzaz, but oddly enough, I think it’s their most forgettable to date. Maybe it’s because I loved The Incredibles so much.
Wanna know my top three for the summer? Tune in tomorrow!